Cart
Your cart is currently empty.

Michaels of Brooklyn Puttan...

Michaels of Brooklyn Puttanesca Sauce is a 32 oz (907 g) jar of bold, briny Brooklyn-made Italian-American tomato sauce built with olives, capers, anchovies, fresh garlic, parsley, basil, and red pepper. It is Non-GMO, gluten free, and has no added sugar, available as a single jar or in a pack of 3, shipped fast from New Jersey.

Michaels of Brooklyn Puttanesca: Olives, Capers, and Anchovies in a Brooklyn Sauce

  • Ten ingredients — tomatoes, Italian olive oil, fresh garlic, olives, capers, anchovies, fresh parsley, fresh basil, red pepper, and spices
  • Classic puttanesca trio — olives, capers, and anchovies give the sauce its briny, savory character with mild heat from red pepper
  • No added sugar — 0 g added sugars; sweetness comes only from ripe tomatoes
  • Non-GMO and gluten free — Non-GMO Project Verified and certified gluten free
  • Contains fish — anchovies mean this sauce is not suitable for vegetarians, vegans, or anyone with a fish allergy
  • Made in Brooklyn, USA — crafted and jarred in Brooklyn, New York; 32 oz (907 g) per jar, sold as a Single or a Pack of 3

How to Use

Warm the sauce gently over medium-low heat and toss with spaghetti or penne, adding a ladle of starchy pasta water to help it coat the noodles; avoid over-reducing, since the briny flavors intensify with simmering. It also works spooned over grilled fish, as a bruschetta topping, or as a baking sauce for chicken. Check for stray olive pits as you eat. Store unopened jars in a cool, dry pantry and refrigerate after opening, using within five to seven days.

About Michaels of Brooklyn

Michaels of Brooklyn began as an Italian restaurant in Brooklyn, New York, in 1964 and later started jarring the sauces served in the dining room. The line includes Marinara, Fresh Tomato and Basil, Puttanesca, and other classic Italian-American sauces, all made with Italian olive oil and no added sugar. The sauces are Non-GMO Project Verified, certified gluten free, and produced in Brooklyn. Browse more jarred sauces in our Pasta Sauce collection. Learn more at michaelsofbrooklyn.com.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Michaels of Brooklyn Puttanesca Sauce contain allergens?
Yes. It contains anchovies (fish), and it is not suitable for vegetarians, vegans, or anyone with a fish allergy. The sauce may also contain olive pits. It is certified gluten free with no dairy or nuts listed. See the printed panel on the jar before eating, since recipes can change between production runs.

How should I store Michaels of Brooklyn Puttanesca Sauce?
Keep the unopened jar in a cool, dry pantry at room temperature. Once opened, replace the lid, refrigerate it, and use the sauce within five to seven days, because it has no preservatives. Leftover sauce freezes well in a sealed container for up to three months. Warm it gently before serving rather than boiling it hard.

How spicy is Michaels of Brooklyn Puttanesca compared with the Marinara?
Puttanesca has mild to medium heat from red pepper, but the dominant flavors are briny and savory from olives, capers, and anchovies rather than hot. It is noticeably bolder and more complex than the seven-ingredient Marinara, which is a simple, mildly sweet tomato sauce with garlic and basil and contains no fish.

Where is Michaels of Brooklyn Puttanesca Sauce made?
It is crafted and jarred in Brooklyn, New York, USA, by the company that grew out of the Michaels of Brooklyn restaurant founded in 1964. The recipe uses Italian olive oil, but the sauce itself is produced domestically. Each unit is a 32 oz (907 g) jar, sold as a Single or a Pack of 3.

  • 5 stars: 22 (100%)
  • 4 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 3 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 2 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 1 star: 0 (0%)
r
reluctant gypsy
Putanesca

Full flavored Putanesca w/the right ingrediants.

C
Cookie
So delicious and authentic too!

Fresh, delicious and authentic. It has anchovies which a lot of other puttanesca sauce doesn’t have. This really tastes like you’re dining in a nice Italian restaurant. I highly recommend!

C
Cookie
Fantastic Sauce

Wonderful Sauce! Excellent quality and taste!! I will always try to keep a jar handy in my pantry!!!

B
Bert B.
Excellent

This is a great puttanesca. The olives and capers are plentiful and the sauce sticks to the pasta. The only way it would be better would be if I made it myself.

t
tlw
Great taste

High quality product taste great pricey but worth every cent.

M
MB
Unordinary Red Sauce

I really wanted to try this because I saw someone talking about it. It’s not your typical Prego or Hunts spaghetti sauce. My family liked it and will buy it again!

S
Savage B
Wow- love it!

Absolutely fabulous! My son brought home a jar of this from a kind of local Italian restaurant with a small store attached. Wow- tastes divine. I want many jars of this in my pantry!! SOOO GOOD

P
Product Reviewer
Excellent Shipping!

Great care went into shipping this bottle. And the sauce is absolutely delicious. Highly Recommend.

A
Anna
So Good!

I keep buying it, cos I can't help myself. I ate every last serving of the last bottle.

R
ROCK
Hubby loved it

ty will order again

K
Kathryn Manness
Most delicious

Yummy! but high in salt. Still, yummy.

J
JohnRascal
Truly Italian Tasty

Why bother cooking tomato sauce when you can buy this delicious sauce. Pop it open and you have the better half of a spaghetti meal. Enough for at least 6 eaters. Enjoy, as I have.

D
Dee
Quality

I have been to the restaurant and the sauce was as good as being there.

d
deborah
The best

Awesome love it

J
John D. Sims
The best

This is the best commercial sauce of its kind that I have been able to find

R
Richard A
Much like grandma made.

A little pricey.

P
Pedro Kovarsky
The best

Simply the best puttanesca I ever had

P
Phil P.
Better than homemade!

I LOVE puttanesca sauce and Michaels makes the absolute BEST around! Other people throw olives in a sauce and call it puttanesca....Michaels is THE REAL THING11111

M
Mary H.
delicious

another great sauce from Michael’s

J
Jeff Power
Five Stars

Some of the best sauce you will ever taste.

M
Mr. Bill
Puttanesca is certainly not your average marinara; however, ...

Puttanesca is certainly not your average marinara; however, if you have a taste for olives this is definitely heaven in a jar!! Michaels of Brooklyn, this Texas boy thanks you very much!!

j
john h. burroughs
I have made Puttanesca Sauce and it is great. However Michaels of Brooklyn is very good

I have made Puttanesca Sauce and it is great. However Michaels of Brooklyn is very good. I no longer make the sauce because Michaels is great!!!!

Loading...