Italian Pasta Brands Worth Buying: Garofalo, Pasta Toscana, Al Dente & More

Most supermarket pasta is made from generic durum wheat blends, extruded through Teflon dies, and dried quickly at high heat — a process that produces fast, cheap, consistent pasta but sacrifices flavor and texture. The best Italian pasta brands use 100% quality durum wheat semolina, bronze-drawing for superior sauce adhesion, and slow low-temperature drying to preserve the wheat’s natural flavor. Here’s a guide to every pasta brand we carry — and which one is right for your kitchen.

What Makes Premium Italian Pasta Different

• Bronze-drawn vs Teflon-drawn: Bronze dies create a rough, porous surface that grips sauce. Teflon dies produce a smooth surface that sauce slides off. This is the single most important quality distinction in pasta production. For more, Serious Eats has tested bronze-drawn vs Teflon pasta in detail.
• 100% durum wheat semolina: Higher protein content than soft wheat, producing a firmer, more elastic pasta that holds its shape when cooked al dente.
• Slow drying: Drying pasta slowly at low temperatures (rather than fast at high heat) preserves flavor and nutritional integrity.
• Geographic certification: Pasta di Gragnano IGP guarantees production in the historic pasta capital of Italy under strict EU standards.

Garofalo — Pasta di Gragnano IGP

Garofalo is produced in Gragnano, near Naples — the historic capital of Italian pasta making since the 16th century. Every Garofalo product carries the Pasta di Gragnano IGP certification, guaranteeing production in this specific region using traditional bronze-drawing and slow drying. 100% durum wheat semolina, Non-GMO.

Garofalo Shapes

• Garofalo Spaghetti No. 9 — 16 oz (453g) — The classic. Bronze-drawn, IGP certified. Perfect for carbonara, aglio e olio, and marinara.
• Garofalo Capellini No. 2 (Angel Hair) — 16 oz (453g) — Very fine, cooks in 2-3 minutes. Best with light olive oil-based sauces.
• Garofalo Fusilli No. 63 — 16 oz (454g) — Spiral shape, excellent sauce-gripping. Non-GMO.
• Garofalo Farfalle No. 78 — 17.6 oz (500g) — Butterfly/bow-tie shape. Versatile — great with cream, pesto, or vegetable sauces.
• Garofalo Orzo No. 26 — 17.6 oz (500g) — Rice-shaped pasta, ready in 5 min. Excellent in soups and as a rice substitute.
• Garofalo Radiatori No. 87 — 16 oz (454g) — Radiator-shaped pasta with exceptional sauce-holding ridges. Great with chunky meat sauces.
• Garofalo Pappardelle No. 1-35 — 16 oz (454g) — Wide ribbon pasta. The classic pairing for wild boar, beef ragù, and mushroom sauces.
• Garofalo Pappardelle — 4-Pack — Value multipack for pappardelle fans.

Pasta Toscana — Certified Organic, 100% Tuscan Wheat

Pasta Toscana is produced in Tuscany using 100% locally grown durum wheat — both certified organic and conventional versions available. For shoppers who prioritize organic certification and traceable Italian sourcing, Pasta Toscana is the cleanest label option in our pasta range.

Pasta Toscana Organic Line

• Pasta Toscana Organic Fusilli — 1 lb
• Pasta Toscana Organic Linguine No. 9 — 1 lb
• Pasta Toscana Organic Penne Rigate — 1 lb
• Pasta Toscana Organic Rigatoni — 1 lb
• Pasta Toscana Organic Spaghetti — 1 lb
• Pasta Toscana Organic Farfalle — 1 lb
• Pasta Toscana Organic Capellini — 16 oz
• Pasta Toscana Organic Pappardelle Nest Egg — 8.82 oz — Egg pasta, nest format. Rich and silky.

Pasta Toscana Conventional Line

• Pasta Toscana Spaghetti — 1 lb
• Pasta Toscana Fusilli — 1 lb
• Pasta Toscana Linguine — 1 lb
• Pasta Toscana Penne Rigate — 1 lb
• Pasta Toscana Rigatoni — 1 lb
• Pasta Toscana Wavy Lasagna — 1 lb — Ideal for classic lasagna and baked pasta dishes.

Al Dente — American Artisan Flavored Pasta

Al Dente is a Michigan-based artisan pasta brand specializing in bold flavored pasta — a category largely absent from the Italian tradition but executed with genuine quality. Their fettuccine range uses real ingredients for flavoring (garlic, squid ink, spinach, basil) and the result is pasta that is genuinely flavorful before any sauce is added. An excellent choice for quick weeknight meals where the pasta itself carries the dish.

• Al Dente Garlic Parsley Fettuccine — 12 oz — Bold garlic flavor baked in. Exceptional with butter, olive oil, or a light cream sauce.
• Al Dente Basil Fettuccine — 12 oz — Fresh basil flavor throughout. Perfect with marinara or a simple tomato sauce.
• Al Dente Squid Ink Fettuccine — 12 oz — Dramatic black pasta from real squid ink. Pairs with seafood sauces, clam sauce, or light olive oil.
• Al Dente Spinach Fettuccine — 12 oz — Earthy spinach flavor, vibrant green color. Excellent with cream or butter sauces.
• Al Dente Spinach Farfalletti — 12 oz — Mini bow-ties with spinach. Great in salads and light pasta dishes.
• Al Dente Golden Egg Bonnetti — 12 oz — Egg pasta in a small shell shape. Rich, classic egg pasta flavor.
• Al Dente Red Lentil + Sweet Potato Pasta — 8 oz — Legume-based, higher protein and fiber. Gluten-free alternative with real vegetable ingredients.
• Al Dente Artisan Pasta — Assorted Varieties — Browse the full range.

Pasta Sauces — Carbone, Barilla & Jersey Italian Gravy

Carbone — New York Restaurant Quality in a Jar

Carbone is one of New York’s most celebrated Italian restaurants. Their jarred pasta sauces use the same quality standard as the restaurant: slow-simmered, no added sugar, gluten-free, no preservatives. A genuine step up from supermarket pasta sauce.

• Carbone Marinara — 15 oz — The classic. No added sugar, slow-simmered.
• Carbone Tomato Basil — 15 oz — Fresh basil, no added sugar.
• Carbone Arrabbiata — 15 oz — Spicy with red chili and garlic.
• Carbone Arrabbiata — 24 oz — Larger format for regular Arrabbiata fans.
• Carbone Classic Vodka Sauce — 15 oz — Creamy tomato with Parmesan and vodka.
• Carbone Roasted Garlic — 15 oz — Deep roasted garlic flavor.
• Carbone Four Cheese — 15 oz — Parmesan, Romano, Asiago and Fontina.

Barilla — Clean-Label Italian Sauces

• Barilla Marinara — 24 oz — No sugar added, reliable everyday sauce.
• Barilla Traditional — 24 oz — No sugar added, gluten free. With basil and oregano.
• Barilla Tomato Basil — 16 oz — Italian tomatoes, fresh basil, no preservatives.

Jersey Italian Gravy — Slow-Simmered Traditional Sauce

• Jersey Italian Gravy — 24 oz Jar — Traditional slow-simmered Italian-style tomato sauce with herbs and spices.
• Jersey Italian Gravy — 4-Pack — Value multipack for regular users.

How to Choose the Right Pasta

• Best overall Italian pasta: Garofalo — IGP certified, bronze-drawn, Pasta di Gragnano
• Best organic Italian pasta: Pasta Toscana Organic — 100% Tuscan durum wheat, USDA organic
• Best for flavored pasta: Al Dente — garlic parsley, squid ink, basil, spinach fettuccine
• Best for lasagna: Pasta Toscana Wavy Lasagna or Garofalo Pappardelle
• Best for soup: Garofalo Orzo or Garofalo Capellini
• Best plant-based option: Al Dente Red Lentil + Sweet Potato Pasta
• Best premium sauce: Carbone (restaurant quality, no added sugar, gluten-free)
• Best everyday sauce: Barilla Marinara or Traditional (no sugar added)

Shop Italian Pasta & Sauces

• Shop Grocery & Gourmet Food
• Shop Canned & Packaged Food

Frequently Asked Questions About Italian Pasta

What is the best Italian pasta brand?

For authentic Italian quality, Garofalo is the top choice — IGP-certified Pasta di Gragnano, bronze-drawn, 100% durum wheat semolina. For certified organic and Tuscan sourcing, Pasta Toscana is the cleanest label option. For flavored artisan pasta, Al Dente offers a unique range of bold fettuccine varieties.

What does bronze-drawn pasta mean?

Bronze-drawn pasta is extruded through bronze dies, creating a rough, porous surface that grips sauce far better than the smooth surface of Teflon-extruded pasta. All Garofalo pasta is bronze-drawn.

What is Pasta di Gragnano IGP?

Pasta di Gragnano IGP is a protected EU geographical indication guaranteeing that pasta is produced in Gragnano, near Naples — the historic capital of Italian pasta-making — using bronze-drawing and slow low-temperature drying. Garofalo carries this certification.

What is Al Dente pasta?

Al Dente is an American artisan pasta brand specializing in flavored fettuccine and specialty shapes — garlic parsley, basil, squid ink, spinach, golden egg, and a red lentil and sweet potato variety. Known for bold flavors and quality ingredients.

What is the difference between Pasta Toscana organic and conventional?

Pasta Toscana offers both USDA certified organic and conventional (non-organic) versions of the same shapes — spaghetti, fusilli, penne rigate, rigatoni, and linguine. Both use 100% Tuscan durum wheat. The organic line carries USDA Organic certification.